1504 – AIO: He (M20) took me (F18) to a Jehovah’s Witness meeting without telling me
Featured on @StorylineReddit: November 3, 2025
She is sitting with her phone in her hand, rereading a message that explains to her how she felt the night before. The tone is affectionate. The reassurance is gentle. And still, something in her chest does not settle.
This story is not really about a dispute over religion. It is about something quieter. A surprise becomes a meeting. Discomfort becomes something temporary, almost imaginary. The conversation moves quickly, smoothly, until she can’t quite locate her original reaction anymore.
Nothing explosive happens at first. No raised voices. No ultimatums. Just small adjustments to her perception, offered as care. By the time the conflict sharpens, it is no longer centered on one evening but on something harder to name: who has the authority to define what that evening meant.
The romance remains present throughout. So does the unease.
The sequence begins with omission. A young woman agrees to a surprise outing, only to realize she has been brought to a religious meeting connected to a faith her partner had not clearly disclosed. She feels caught off guard but stays, partly out of politeness, partly because he seems proud to show her this part of himself.
When she later tries to articulate discomfort, the tone of the exchange shifts. He reframes the experience as positive, reassures her that she was never truly uneasy, and emphasizes how well she fit in. Her uncertainty softens in response. The focus drifts from what she felt to how the evening should be understood.
External feedback prompts her to reassess. She initiates a clearer conversation about long-term compatibility and states directly that she will not join his faith. The relationship ends calmly.
Then the final message arrives. What had been framed as mutual affection is recast as moral compromise. The arc moves from private confusion to ideological distance, and the terms of the relationship are rewritten in retrospect.
AIO: He (M20) took me (F18) to a Jehovah’s Witness meeting without telling me CONCLUDED I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/NervousCandle0010
Originally posted to r/AmIOverreacting
AIO: He (M20) took me (F18) to a Jehovah’s Witness meeting without telling me
Editor’s note: made small edits for ease of readability
Trigger Warnings: manipulation, gaslighting, proselytization, deception, religious coercion, possible misogyny
Original Post: October 17, 2025
We have been dating for like 2 months. He’s really sweet and spoils me. However I’m still irked and something feels off and I just can’t let it go.
Yesterday we hung out, and when I brought it up again, he shut it down. He somehow makes me think it’s nothing and changes the subject and I don’t even notice it. I don’t want to keep nagging him, but I’m still not satisfied. My friends say I overthink and ruin good things, but I can’t let it go I’m still upset it happened but I don’t know if I’m over doing it. I promise you I’m not discriminating his religion it’s just weird. This whole thing is.
Am I overreacting? I’m not confrontational I just need advice
Also throw away
EDIT: After reading everyone’s comments I will be updating after I speak to him.
The text messages
Transcript of the text messages
Guy is in black bubbles, OOP is in blue bubbles
Guy: Hey you’ve been quiet all day… you haven’t returned any of my calls.
Guy: Is everything okay?
OOP: Sorry I’m fine just needed a little time to think about last night.
Guy: The meeting part? I thought you enjoyed it babe.
OOP: Yea it was okay I guess.
OOP: I thought this surprise would maybe be something more casual like a dinner or a film not this tbh.
Guy: It was a surprise though… a good one.
Guy: I wanted to show you something really personal, something that’s important to me, I thought this is the part of getting to know each other thing.
OOP: I get that and I guess that makes sense.
OOP: But I didn’t even know you were Jehovah’s and you didn’t even tell me until you took me there.
OOP: I fell like you should have told me yk? :/
OOP: Feel*
OOP: I thought you were Christian.
Guy: I am, it’s just a branch of it.
Guy: I didn’t mean to hide it… it just never came up naturally. I thought it would be better if you saw it for yourself instead of believing what people say about it.
OOP: Idk I just feel caught off guard.
OOP: And I didn’t know anyone.
Guy: Yes but you were amazing honestly, everyone noticed how warm and kind you are.
Guy: And they loved meeting you.
OOP: Really?
Guy: I’m not joking babe you they were all fond of you.
OOP: Thanks I appreciated it… it’s just I just felt a little out of place yk?
Guy: That’s because it’s a new experience for you and that’s okay.
OOP: Maybe I was a little uncomfortable too.
Guy: You weren’t uncomfortable, really… you just didn’t know and now you do and the night went great wouldn’t you agree?
OOP: I guess so
Guy: You could’ve left anytime but you didn’t, and that’s because you were open to understanding something new and that says a lot about you babe
OOP: I didn’t see it that way so thank you
Guy: I’m proud of you for giving it a chance. Don’t over think it please
OOP: Thank you and I won’t
End of the transcript
Relevant / Top Comments
Commenter 1: He literally told you that you weren’t uncomfortable. He told you, “no, you felt like THIS.”
Thats cult/kidnapping – level gaslighting.
I’ve been to one of these meetings. They looked at you like a new piece of meat.
Run for the hills.
OOP: Every person there said hello to me and made me feel so welcomed but not once I felt at ease.
Commenter 2: Yeah, “You weren’t uncomfortable” and “you could have left any time, but you didn’t” made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
OOP: I didn’t leave because I didn’t want to be rude… he seemed so happy
Commenter 3: Do you want to be a jehovah witness? Like, long term with this guy, that’s what is going to happen.
OOP: After reading everyone’s comments, this has been very eye opening and I’m going to make my decision soon. And no, I have no plans of being a Jehovah’s Witness.
Edit I’m overwhelmed with all of this new and insightful information. Everyone’s telling me to dump him right away. Let me think about this and I will make my decision. I’ve been dating this guy and I can’t switch my feelings off like a tap. I appreciate everyone’s input. I just need time to think what I think is best for me and how to move forward. My heart is hurting.
Commenter 4: That’s really cool of him to let you know how you felt about it
Commenter 5: as an ex-jw this is so crazy because I know they bombarded you all meeting you😭 He def took you to a meeting to try to convert you because JWs do not believe in relationships with “worldly” (non witness) people. Girl run
edit: any of my comments are just my experience growing up! I’m glad some of you had better ones 🙂 I’m sure area plays a huge part on this! To those with similar experiences, I’m sorry 🫶 it feels good to know I’m not the only one though!
Update: October 20, 2025 (three days later)
I spent so many hours reading everyone’s advice here, things finally made sense for me.
We hung out yesterday and I just started asking him questions about his faith. He was pretty honest, said he really sees his future with a girl who’s also a Jehovah’s Witness. And then I told him I have zero plans, now or ever, to get into his faith, practice it, or even learn about it. You could see his whole mood change then. He tried telling me with a bunch of ‘what if’ situations lol but I just kept saying no.
Anyways I said “’Look, there’s no future here, it’s probably best we just end this” He agreed. It actually ended pretty maturely, and he was sweet about it. Then today, I get this message from him lolol.
Seriously, thank you to everyone who commented. Your advice really woke me up. I honestly just needed someone a bit older and wiser to tell me my gut feeling about that first church meeting was valid, cause none of my friends really got why I was so uncomfortable 🙁
The text messages
Transcript of the text messages
Guy is in black bubbles, OOP is in blue bubbles
Guy: I’m gonna get this off my chest and then I’m done I don’t expect a reply, actually don’t reply at all
Guy: You couldn’t commit to anything real… always chasing whatever felt good for a second in this world
Guy: That’s why you’ll always be stuck looking for something more, but never finding it where it matters… in the light… in faith.
Guy: I actually tried to fool myself about you… tried to make myself believe we could work, even tho my gut was screaming no. In almost 3 months I’ve sinned and done things I’m not proud of you’ve brought the worst out of me [redacted]
Guy: You made me want to forget it all … made me do stupid things, just to get a feeling that disappeared anyway…
Guy: I’m disgusted with myself and I’m only realising that now
Guy: I’m glad it’s over so I can focus on myself and my faith. You’re just… unsaveable. Too far gone into everything that doesn’t matter.
Guy: There’s no getting through that… no changing you. I’m glad we ended this, it’s better this way… All the best with whatever you’re looking for.
OOP: Ok and gd luck with whatever ur battling because you really need it
End of transcript
Relevant / Top Comments
Commenter 1: Our guts are rarely wrong but we have taught to ignore them to make others happy. You definitely dodged a bullet.
OOP: I’m glad I posted on here. It was a good reality check. I just couldn’t let it go. And I’m glad I didn’t
Commenter 2: Your response is perfect
OOP: Thank you I was actually going to write “that’s really hurtful” lol. But I’m glad I didn’t. I just want to move on.
Commenter 3: That was the point of him sending you all of those nasty texts. He was trying to upset you. Don’t let him think he even has the ability to hurt you. As an older, somewhat wiser person, I would encourage you to you to be more firm in your statements. You pushed back when he was gaslighting you (which was so good), but you also seemed uncertain, so he felt like he could continue to push you. People treat you how you allow them to treat you. As a woman raised in the south to be a people pleaser, it took me way too long to fully grasp that statement. Keep up the good work!
OOP: I think I am a people pleaser and I can’t help it it’s my biggest struggle. Idk why I’m like this. 😞It’s like I don’t have a voice and I just want to keep the harmony. Everyone’s advice on my last thread gave me a boost of confidence and it helped me end this. I’m so grateful.
Commenter 4: I love the part where he blames you for him ‘sinning.’ Very nice of him to encapsulate one of the things you had to look forward to if you stayed with him. Congratulations! I’m glad you dodged this bullet.
OOP: I really wanted to call him out for that because every time he was the one initiating it and honestly it was a mutual thing. Somehow it’s all my fault now haha.
Commenter 5: I hope this makes you more confident in trusting your gut instincts!! Don’t let people talk you out of what you instinctively know to be true. Congrats on dodging that bullet, and here’s to standing up for yourself
OOP: Thank you!! I owe it to everyone’s advice! Never again I’ll ignore my instincts.
Editor’s note: marking this concluded that OOP has deleted her account and the issue has been resolved
He tells her she wasn’t uncomfortable. The night went great. Wouldn’t she agree? She replies, “I guess so.”
The exchange is short. Compliments appear between clarifications. He calls her warm. He says everyone loved her. She thanks him. There are ellipses. There is a pause before she answers. The tone stays soft.
At first glance, it reads like reassurance. But something more structural is taking shape. When one partner consistently supplies the interpretation of events, the center of gravity shifts. She begins with a feeling. He offers a corrected version. She adjusts. The conversation moves on.
His position is not cartoonish or openly hostile. For him, faith is not an accessory; it organizes his future. Introducing her to that space may feel intimate, even hopeful. From his perspective, the evening might genuinely have gone well. That sincerity matters. It complicates the reading.
And then the scale widens. In a community where partnership and belief are tightly aligned, compatibility is not casual. When she says she has no intention of joining, the conversation tightens. The tone changes quickly. There is no shouting. Just a hard pivot toward moral language.
He lists regret. He describes himself as having sinned. He says she brought out the worst in him.
The escalation unfolds in text. Statement after statement. The relationship is recast as spiritually contaminating. That reframing stands on its own.
Her final response is brief. No argument. No emotional counterweight. Just a line wishing him luck with whatever he is battling.
What lingers is less the breakup than the earlier moment the ease with which her discomfort was translated for her, and how close she came to accepting that translation.
Featured on @StorylineReddit: November 11, 2025 It starts in a tire shop. Fluorescent lights, the smell of rubber, a mechanic […]
Scroll to Top
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
